How Can I Get an Impartial Property Report in Sicily?

My colleagues and I are very proud of the work we put into selecting the homes you’ll find listed on our site. Every one of them has been viewed in person by our team, who have chosen them based on their appeal to international buyers. We’re always trying to bring you the best of new markets all across the island of Sicily, and our selection is growing every year. Of course, if you ask any of us for our view on any one of them, we would be happy to say it represents good value, but as we’re the selling agency, I’d understand if you wanted a second opinion..

Where we can, however, give a completely impartial opinion is when we’re asked about properties from whose sale we have nothing to gain. If you find a piece of real estate in Sicily that’s offered for sale privately or through another agency, and it’s not convenient to visit it in person, you can rely on a very important service that we’re always happy to offer any prospective buyer.

If you need a fully independent property report, myself or one of our team can arrange a viewing of any home, anywhere in Sicily and provide you with our considered professional opinion. You will receive photos, videos and a detailed written analysis of what’s on sale. Our fee is fixed and the same whatever the verdict, so we have no reason to tell you anything but the truth.

Why does an independent view matter?

In Italy every offer has to be backed by a deposit, often around €10,000, and once the seller accepts, both sides are bound by it. That’s obviously an extremely serious commitment to make on the strength of listing photos and a short agency-written text.

Italian law already requires agents to act fairly towards both buyer and seller, and the vast majority of our colleagues in the region are trustworthy professionals who take that responsibility very seriously. Even so, any agent handling a sale will earn a commission when it goes through. A second opinion from someone with no stake in the outcome gives you a much firmer basis for your decision, especially when you’re buying away from your home country and working in a second language.

In the past, some clients who have appreciated our reports have asked us to remain involved and help them out with the purchase, taking advantage of the multilingual support we can offer and the trust they’ve built in our work. We’ve found that local agencies are usually willing to collaborate in this way if it’s something a buyer wants to pursue – but of course there’s no obligation whatsoever, so that option doesn’t colour our appraisal of the property at all.

Who visits the property?

Many years ago, my father Thomas, the founder of our agency, began offering informal appraisals to friends from his native country of Germany. He had moved south without any of this kind of support, and understood how important it was to feel like you had some local knowledge in your corner when finding and bidding for a property. Over the ensuing years, he has appraised literally hundreds of Sicilian homes, and he trained myself and my colleagues Fabian, Romolo and Gaetano personally. I handle a lot of the visits myself, but any one of us might be your eyes and ears depending on the region and everyone’s diaries.

Something we should be completely honest about is the fact that none of us is a surveyor, nor an engineer. There’s no real equivalent here of the chartered surveyor buyers would automatically engage in many northern European markets, and we’re not technicians or architects. For specialist queries relating to large scale renovation work, hydrology, seismology and so forth we’re always happy to put you in touch with leading local professionals we trust completely.

What we do bring is unbeatable market insight, and an understanding of the standards international buyers expect, and an ability to anticipate the questions they might not think to ask.

What exactly do we look for?

The house and its paperwork

When you ask me for a report, I act exactly as if I were considering making an offer myself. Before the visit I’ll check through whatever documents the seller or their agency has shared.  When I arrive at the property the first thing I do is compare them with the building itself. This is the quickest way to spot any unregistered changes, such as an enclosed terrace or an extension that hasn’t been recorded on the plans. The notary who checks the same plans for title claim doesn’t visit the house, so catch these discrepancies early is vital.

Then I go through carefully room by room, noting its plumbing and anything that will need attention, from the roof and windows to damp, wiring and bathrooms. That lets us give you a realistic idea of the work involved and our wide network of local tradespeople help us cost out the project on your behalf.

I’ll take photos and a video that shows you the whole home, in a single take wherever possible. If we’re out in open countryside I love the chance to get the drone out and give you a bird’s eye view. Finally, before I leave I’ll always ask myself, what can I tell you that you’d never know without being here in person? 

The street and the surroundings

Even the best-written property listings rarely mention what’s next door, so after saying goodbye to the vendor or agent, we walk around the area. Of course, we’re interested in what’s nearby, but really paying attention to the things you won’t see from a map. How heavy is the traffic, are there any other sources of noise, could there be smells from nearby homes or businesses? We’ll try to get a sense of what the neighbours are like and what condition the local infrastructure is in.

Back at the office, we’ll collate all the images we took and put our thoughts into a report. You’ll get free access to all of this through a shared drive, so you can study it all whenever is convenient and as often as you like.

How has it helped past buyers?

Not every visit brings good news, and I would always rather tell a client about a problem early on than have them discover it after they’ve made a bid or even moved in. Sometimes we’ve found cracks that didn’t show in the listing photos, or a bit of damp, or issues with the roof or plumbing. This summer I viewed a beautiful villa a little way away from a motorway. The road looked comfortably distant on the map but the shape of the valley carried the sound straight up to the house, and the buyer ended up finding somewhere quieter. One time last year my father discovered a brand new building site opposite a house that was going to block part of its sea view.

Happily, it often goes the other way. It’s always nice to be able to tell a client about friendly neighbours, and on one trip I stayed overnight at a B&B run by a lovely German couple who introduced us to a welcoming expat community in the village. It’s always a bonus to be able to give a property our full endorsement.

How much does it cost?

A visit with a full property report in the province of Palermo, where we’re based, costs €350 plus VAT (IVA). Further afield we invoice travel costs and time on top, but we always agree these with you beforehand, so there’s never a surprise on the bill. If you’d like us to view several properties in the same area, naturally these expenses can be streamlined.

If you’d rather keep costs down, we can skip the written report and speak to you on a video call straight after the visit for a reduced fee. You’ll still hear everything we think about the house while it’s fresh in our minds.

If there’s a house on your shortlist that you can’t easily come and see, send us the link and tell us what matters most to you. We’ll let you know who can visit, when and what it will cost.